Is Philanthropy Going to the Dogs?

 Transcript Now Available! Click here (PDF format, 33 pages, 215 KB)

A complete, edited transcript is now available of the panel discussion on September 5 co-hosted by Hudson Institute's Bradley Center for Philanthropy and Civic Renewal and The Chronicle of Philanthropy, entitled:

Is Philanthropy Going to the Dogs?

Friday, September 5, 2008 - 12:00 to 2:00 p.m.
Hudson Institute - Betsy and Walter Stern Conference Center
1015 15th Street, NW - Suite 600
Washington, DC 20005

Event Description

When Leona Helmsley died in August 2007, she left all but a few million dollars of her perhaps $8 billion estate to the Leona M. and Harry B. Helmsley Charitable Trust, making it easily one of America’s largest foundations. She also left a brief document indicating that the entire trust be used for the care and welfare of dogs. “The trustees recently hired a philanthropic advisory service to help them figure out a way to remain true to Mrs. Helmsley’s intentions while at the same time pursuing broader charitable goals with her foundation,” reported the New York Times (“Helmsley Left Dogs Billions in Her Will,” July 2).

“If it were only a matter of Leona Helmsley wasting her money, no one would need to care. But she is wasting ours, too,” wrote Boston College Law School professor RAY MADOFF in a July 9 New York Times op-ed (see "Background Reading," below). Rather than pay estate taxes of $3.6 billion to the government, Helmsley has stipulated that the money be held in trust for perpetuity. Madoff argues in her op-ed that “the law should not encourage people to tie up their resources – and ours – for all time.”

Palmer, Madoff, Schambra, Lenkowsky, Eisenberg

Indiana University professor of public affairs and philanthropic studies LESLIE LENKOWSKY suggests that Helmsley may have been trying to support animal welfare as a heretofore neglected charitable cause compared to, say, child welfare – and that Congress and the American people give her that right. “In a society that values individual rights, philanthropy gives those with such differing views opportunities to act on them constructively, regardless of what others may think,” he wrote in the Chronicle of Philanthropy's August 21 issue (see "Background Reading," below).

On Friday, September 5, Hudson Institute’s Bradley Center for Philanthropy and Civic Renewal and The Chronicle of Philanthropy hosted Professors Madoff and Lenkowsky, along with Georgetown University’s PABLO EISENBERG and Hudson Institute’s JUDGE ROBERT BORK to discuss the fundamental questions Helmsley’s bequest raises about donor intent, social justice, and the public interest. The Chronicle’s STACY PALMER moderated the discussion.

Background Reading

• - "Dog Eat Your Taxes?" by Ray D. Madoff, New York Times, July 9, 2008 (PDF format, 2 pages, 25 KB)
• - "Should a Big Bequest Go to the Dogs?" by Leslie Lenkowsky, Chronicle of Philanthropy issue dated August 21, 2008 (online or in PDF format, 2 pages, 82 KB)
• - "Vision of Philanthropy: The Challenge to Foundation Trustees" by Pablo Eisenberg, a speech to the annual meeting of trustees of the Northern California Grantmakers, March 8, 1988 (PDF format, 8 pages, 76 KB)
• - "Raising Some $25 Trillion Questions" and "New Giving Reflects Old Priorities" by Pablo Eisenberg, Chronicle of Philanthropy, December 16, 1999 and March 9, 2000, respectively (PDF format, 5 pages, 33 KB)
• - "Interpreting the Founder's Vision" by Robert H. Bork, in Donor Intent (Philanthropy Roundtable, 1993), pp. 3-13 (PDF format, 6 pages, 527 KB)

   

Program and Panel

11:45 a.m.
Registration, lunch buffet

12:00 p.m.
Welcome by Hudson Institute's WILLIAM SCHAMBRA

12:10
Panel discussion
RAY MADOFF, Boston College
LESLIE LENKOWSKY, Indiana University
PABLO EISENBERG, Georgetown University
JUDGE ROBERT BORK, Hudson Institute
STACY PALMER (moderator), The Chronicle of Philanthropy

1:10
Question-and-answer session

2:00
Adjournment

Further Information

To request further information on this event or the Bradley Center, please contact Hudson Institute at (202) 974-2424 or e-mail Kristen at kmcintyre@hudson.org.